diff --git a/Account/Sources/Account/ReaderAPI/ReaderAPIAccountDelegate.swift b/Account/Sources/Account/ReaderAPI/ReaderAPIAccountDelegate.swift
index 63d4768f1..46e66b540 100644
--- a/Account/Sources/Account/ReaderAPI/ReaderAPIAccountDelegate.swift
+++ b/Account/Sources/Account/ReaderAPI/ReaderAPIAccountDelegate.swift
@@ -353,10 +353,6 @@ final class ReaderAPIAccountDelegate: AccountDelegate {
 						switch subResult {
 						case .created(let subscription):
 							self.createFeed(account: account, subscription: subscription, name: name, container: container, completion: completion)
-						case .alreadySubscribed:
-							DispatchQueue.main.async {
-								completion(.failure(AccountError.createErrorAlreadySubscribed))
-							}
 						case .notFound:
 							DispatchQueue.main.async {
 								completion(.failure(AccountError.createErrorNotFound))
diff --git a/Account/Sources/Account/ReaderAPI/ReaderAPICaller.swift b/Account/Sources/Account/ReaderAPI/ReaderAPICaller.swift
index 2c15af057..ae5b29476 100644
--- a/Account/Sources/Account/ReaderAPI/ReaderAPICaller.swift
+++ b/Account/Sources/Account/ReaderAPI/ReaderAPICaller.swift
@@ -12,7 +12,6 @@ import Secrets
 
 enum CreateReaderAPISubscriptionResult {
 	case created(ReaderAPISubscription)
-	case alreadySubscribed
 	case notFound
 }
 
@@ -375,7 +374,7 @@ final class ReaderAPICaller: NSObject {
 
 						switch subResult?.numResults {
 						case 0:
-							completion(.success(.alreadySubscribed))
+							completion(.success(.notFound))
 						default:
 							guard let streamId = subResult?.streamId else {
 								completion(.failure(AccountError.createErrorNotFound))